Allison Mao Week 5: Is Being Bilingual Important?


Apparently, twenty-three states in the US do not require two years of a foreign language in high school. That means that twenty-seven of them do require them. But why is this the case? Wouldn’t it make more sense to have all of the states either respect or disregard this requirement for the sake of uniformity? 


Art Carden, in this case, should prefer that schools not enforce the requirement to learn another language. He acknowledges on Forbes that it would be very beneficial to learn a new language but counters that simply we do not learn enough of it to actually be able to put these skills to good use. 


I’m able to relate to these concerns as well. I’ve been taking Chinese classes since I was five years old; my Chinese still is only proficient at best. My understanding of verbal conversations is my strong suit, probably because I am able to listen to my parents talk in Chinese at home. However, if I were to learn a new language without native speakers to reference in day-to-day life, things would be much more difficult. Not only this, two years is nothing compared to over a decade of learning my parent’s mother tongue. If I’m unable to master Chinese even after all this time, I feel like there would be no way I could master a separate language so quickly. This is the problem of foreign languages in the United States—there is simply not enough emphasis on learning them. 


Still, there are many benefits to learning a new language. It allows you to be able to understand more and is able to communicate with a larger demographic of people. It opens a door to new media, cultures, and so much more. Perhaps that is why the US does not focus on promoting the understanding of another language as much as other countries: English is a language that is very beneficial to learn already. There is simply not as much of an incentive to learn another language when we are already learning a language that often dominates both national and international affairs.  


Although these points are able to explain the lack of emphasis on foreign languages compared to other countries, it might not be a good thing to simply rely on English. Countries with English as the national language may not always be the most influential countries in the world. It might be good to learn other languages in case power and opportunities shift elsewhere; we would then be able to guarantee a higher chance of success. 


There is no right or wrong answer to this problem, and both sides have their merits. At this rate, we might as well wait and see where the future takes us. 

Source:

Carden, Art. "Should Schools Require Foreign Languages? Doubtful.." Forbes, 22 May 2018, 

www.forbes.com/sites/artcarden/2018/05/22/should-schools-require-foreign-languages

             -doubtful/?sh=4110e6592303. Accessed 18 Oct. 2023.

Comments

  1. Sana ThakkarOctober 25, 2023 at 11:08 AM

    Hey Allison! You made some interesting points in this blog which really got me thinking. I finished my three required years of Spanish last year, but I simply do not remember a lot of what I learned due to lack of stimulation. So, in that sense, I agree that learning a language in school can be pretty useless. However, you made a good argument about how useful it is to know multiple languages, creating a conflicting thought process. My confusion and elaboration proves the effectiveness of your multiple counter arguments, which I admired as you were stating the pros and cons of both perspectives. What furthered my contemplation was your open ending. By not picking a side, you open the stage to some fruitful discussion, which I really appreciated.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Patrick ChouOctober 25, 2023 at 9:50 PM

    Hi Allison! I feel like learning a new language outside of school similar to how you started at 5 is super beneficial. However, I think that 3 years is simply not enough and that that would be a constraint of the American education system. I feel that if children could start at for example in sixth grade it would be beneficial for critical thinking skills alongside the benefit of learning a new language. I think by tackling on both sides of the argument it provides a sense of complexity and sprouts discussion. This topic has always been very open, and I think you provided information for background that provides information for a person to take a side.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Muhammed AliOctober 29, 2023 at 9:38 AM

    Hi Allison! I think your take on language in the public school system is very accurate, and you conveyed your ideas really well. The point you made about 2 years not being enough to be proficient in a language is extremely true. Before high school, I had been learning Arabic for around 10 years, and I'm mid at it at best. Perhaps that's just because I was younger when I was learning it initially, but regardless, 2 years will still not be enough. I also find it very interesting that not all states follow the two years of foreign language requirement. I wonder if the state colleges have different entry requirements then too. My only critique of the blog is that I have no idea who Art Carden is. It might be helpful next time if you introduce your sources and give a little bit of context before saying what they think. Overall, great blog!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Aarya Patil Week 8 : The Evolution of the American Language

Image
American English, is a vibrant language, with several different strands, which showcases its evolution. It presents the combination of varying influences, each one leaving a clear mark on the language we speak today.  The American language may seem weird for new learners. As one article points out, “the spelling doesn’t match the pronunciation.” Imagine coming to America as an immigrant, and having to learn this language. It would seem like an almost impossible task due to all the grammar rules, ironic spellings, and homophonic words. However, it is all these quirks that make the American English language as unique as it is. According to a 2023 survey, English is the number one language spoken in the world!  As we are taking ourselves back to the 1920s in class, the jazz era covered by F. Scott Fitzgerald's "The Great Gatsby," showcases a much different language than many of us have heard before. The Roaring Twenties introduced a vivid array of phrases and terms that were
Read more

Mahesh - Week 8: A Necessity for Consideration

Image
  Mahesh - Week 8: A Necessity for Consideration The English language has experienced a change due to pop culture, exemplified by the popularity of rap songs and the value that younger generations give to these types of music. If we take the time to reflect on the progression of the English language in a colloquial sense, it is noteworthy that English speakers have become more remiss in their adherence to the grammatical rules that compose the language. English, like any other language, has endured changes that have redefined the limits of what is acceptable in an informal setting. Texting, for example, is a prevalent form of communication that many Americans employ to convey their thoughts. Although an instrument for rapid communication, texting has contorted parts of English. For example, many texters prefer using “u” rather than “you,” demonstrating how many veer away from English grammatical principles. The shortening of phrases that texting institutes among the American public may
Read more

Sana Thakkar Week 8: Hollywood's Global Influence

Image
          The room darkens, and all focus shifts to a singular light. Suddenly, you find yourself at 4 Privet Drive with obnoxious screaming from a large angry man, and a quiet boy with an odd scar on his head. Before you know it, you're in a high-speed car chase with a man named Ethan Hunt, who is driving a sleek black BMW off of a cliff, while somehow assuring you of your survival. A loud squeal later, you are in a fashionable New York City apartment with a women who claims to be a thirteen year old stuck in a thirty year old's body.       From "Harry Potter" and "Mission Impossible" to "13 going on 30",  Hollywood creates immersive worlds, transporting its audience into an exciting and enticing experience. The U.S. film industry has affirmed its rightful place on the world stage, creating rippling effects in societies globally, allowing the dominance of American pop culture since the mid-twentieth century.       Disney, one of Hollywood's mo
Read more